7 Gifts You Shouldn’t Waste Your Money On (And What To Give Instead)
All featured products and deals are selected independently and objectively by the author. Better Report may receive a share of sales via affiliate links in content.
We mean well when we’re shopping for gifts, but sometimes we end up giving something that goes into the donation pile or gathers dust in the back of a closet. “The worst gift purchases share one trait: They carry a high price tag but zero usage after week three,” says Andrew Gosselin, a certified public accountant at the coupon database Save My Cent.
What makes it worse is that it’s the gesture behind the gift that makes people keep it well after they actually want it. “Many people love shopping and gift-giving, especially at the holidays. And recipients know this about the gift giver,” says Amy Slenker-Smith, a Becker certified professional organizer. “That’s what makes the items hard to get rid of later.”
We’re helping you avoid awkward thank-yous and strained smiles by sharing which gifts to skip and which to get instead.
Table of Contents: Gifts You Should Give • Gifts To Avoid
Gifts You Should Give This Holiday Season
When it comes to finding gifts someone will actually enjoy, Gosselin likes to use a guiding principle: “The best gifts eliminate a recurring annoyance rather than adding a new object to a shelf.”
According to Slenker-Smith, “The goal isn’t to buy nothing, but rather to be intentional and thoughtful about what you buy.”
Below, you’ll find the types of gifts our experts suggested giving, and our favorite product picks that fit the bill. The experts didn’t endorse specific products.
Premium Upgrades

Gosselin recommends gifting an upgraded version of products “the person already buys and replaces.” For example, a coffee lover may appreciate a high-quality grinder that doesn’t take up a ton of space. A writer is sure to love an engraved pen, and someone with a new passion for cooking may appreciate a professional knife set.
Reader Favorites

Service-Related Gifts
Both Gosselin and Slinker-Smith recommend gifting a service that frees up some of your loved one’s time.
“Last year, one of my clients paid for a cleaning lady for each of her three daughters who were married with little kids,” Slinker-Smith says. “They were all over the moon to receive this gift from their mom.”
Popular services, such as Merry Maids or HappyNest, allow you to purchase a gift certificate for cleaning or laundry service.

Cacao Bliss
Looking for a gift that feels like a treat but works like a wellness ritual? Cacao Bliss blends 100% organic ceremonial-grade cacao with turmeric, cinnamon, MCTs, and monk fruit. It tastes like the richest hot chocolate, yet has only about 35 calories a cup. Your loved one can swap it for morning coffee and enjoy steady energy from theobromine with no jitters or crash. One study found raw cacao nearly doubled GLP-1, the fullness hormone. With a 60-day money-back guarantee, it’s the gift they will happily sip all year. [PARTNER]

Cover a Bill
Gosselin also recommends “cash in a form that doesn’t feel like cash, like loading their transit card or covering a bill.” It’s the kind of gift that’s especially appreciated in today’s economy: When household finances are stretched thin, he says, “a gift that removes a bill or an irritation lands harder than a gift that adds an object.”
AT&T and Verizon Wireless make it easy to pay another person’s phone bill online. However, depending on your giftee’s needs, you may simply want to call the business itself for help, whether it’s their local utility company or landlord.
You can even pay toward or completely pay off someone’s student loan if you’re feeling particularly generous, but be aware that there may be tax implications depending on the size of your gift.

Consumable Gifts
Gosselin and Slenker-Smith both recommend consumables as gifts. This category includes not just food items, but anything that needs to be replaced frequently.
“Consumables are temporary and appreciated by people who are trying to own less or thinking about downsizing,” Slenker-Smith says. “For my own gift-giving, I make a lot of homemade consumable gifts like homemade vanilla extract and a jar brownie mix. My friends and family look forward to it every year. Yes, it takes time, but that time is what makes it such a welcome gift.”
Gosselin suggests ideas such as “good olive oil, a nice pepper mill with the refills, quality socks, [or] real maple syrup.”
You may even consider “gift cards to a grocery store,” Gosselin says. “There’s no wrong size, no return trip, and groceries are the one line item nobody has cut out of their budget.”
If you’re living away from the giftee and not sure where they shop the most, you may consider a gift card to an online grocery delivery service, such as Instacart or DoorDash.

Create (or Add to) an Experience
Gifts that create a memory will linger longer than an item put on a shelf. Slenker-Smith suggests giving them a night out at “a restaurant they’ve mentioned wanting to try, a cooking class, theater tickets that they wouldn’t buy for themselves, or a zoo or museum membership.” You may even want to get one for yourself, so you can enjoy the time together.
“Experience gifts work because nothing has to be stored, cleaned, maintained, or eventually removed,” she explains.
You could also consider adding to an experience they have coming up. For instance, if they’re starting a new job, consider inviting them on a shopping trip to pick out an outfit for their first day. Or if they’re traveling soon, buy them a new luggage set or a travel journal to take along.
With all the deals and advertising that happen leading up to the holiday season, it can be hard to figure out what to give and what to skip. “Choose quality over quantity,” Slenker-Smith advises. You should also “ask yourself where it will live. If you can’t picture the exact spot in their house, don’t buy it.”
Gifts To Avoid Wasting Money On

Smart Home Gadgets
Smart home gadgets are among the worst gifts you can buy, according to Gosselin. “A $130 smart picture frame or specialty kitchen appliance looks impressive unwrapped, then sits in a closet,” he says. The problem lies in the complicated setup, which often requires an account and a challenging Wi-Fi configuration. That leads to wasting “20 minutes nobody wants to spend on Christmas morning.”

Gift Sets
As pretty as a gift set and its packaging may be, both Gosselin and Slenker-Smith advise against them. “The bundled lotion-candle-soap box sells for $45 when the single item the recipient actually wants retails for $22,” Gosselin says.
“This is a very generic gift, given without a lot of thought,” Slenker-Smith notes. “Thousands of them are given every year and end up in the donation pile.” It’s better to buy your loved one the item that they actually want separately and wrap it with your own attractive paper and bows.

Novelty Subscriptions
A novelty subscription sounds charming but comes with complications. “A three-month sock or snack club runs $60 to $90 and generates a renewal charge that the recipient has to remember to cancel,” Gosselin says. It turns into a challenge for the recipient — “you’ve given someone a chore with a bow on it,” Gosselin notes — or for yourself, if you’ve entered in your own credit card information to send out the gift.

Countertop Appliances and Viral Gadgets
Slenker-Smith advises avoiding big kitchen countertop appliances, such as bread machines, Instant Pots, or noodle makers. While they are generous gifts, she often ends up loading them in her car for donation when working with clients.
“The problem isn’t the appliance,” she explains. “It’s the counter.” The appliance takes up space needed for cooking or meal prep, and “what was meant as a gift becomes one more thing to store, and one more decision to make.”
Another thing to skip? “The viral kitchen item of the moment,” Gosselin says. “If it got popular on TikTok in September, it’ll be discounted 40% in January and listed on Facebook Marketplace by March.”

Unwanted Hobby Gifts
While it’s a whimsical idea for someone to start a clever hobby because of a gift, it may not be a good idea unless you know for certain it’s of interest to them. In Slenker-Smith’s experience, “the sourdough kit, the yoga mat, the gardening set … come to the donation pile more than almost anything, and usually unopened.”

Seasonal Gifts
Seasonal gifts are another no-no, according to Slenker-Smith. Skip the holiday-themed decor, dishes, or “anything that needs its own storage. A gift that lives in a bin 11 months out of the year is one more thing to find a home for.”
Featured Image Credit: © New Africa/stock.adobe.com
More From Our Network
Better Report is part of Inbox Studio, an email-first media company. *Indicates a third-party property.


